Consistent Style and a Bit of Restraint Make This the Most Entertaining Season So Far.
In Series 5, "Agatha Christie's Marple" has finally settled on a consistent style. The bold palette looks like Technicolor, and the acting style is also reminiscent of the decade in which the mysteries take place, the 1950s. We've seen this off-and-on in previous seasons, but now it has lost its clumsiness. Although the mysteries are sordid and melodramatic, they don't go over the top to the point of distraction, as has sometimes been the case in previous seasons. Again the writers have adapted various source materials to serve Miss Marple. "The Mirror Crack'd from Side to Side" is, of course, a Marple novel. But "The Secret of Chimneys" is a Superintendent Battle novel whose plot has been entirely changed. And "The Blue Geranium" is adapted from a Marple short story.
Julia McKenzie plays Marple as a practical, plainspoken woman whom one would probably not mistake for a dotty old lady. The extent to which the police detectives do, however, varies. In "The Secret of...
Acorn Media delivers the original uncut 89 minute U.K. versions.
First let me say that I have these DVDs in hand & have watched them, they are the uncut 89 minute U.K. versions, not the trimmed versions shown on PBS.
Of the new Marple series, this is probably the best set yet.
Julia Mckenzie is more at ease in her second year as Miss Marple. She explains her take on the character in a texted interview. She feels that the early Miss Marple stories depict the sleuth as a fragile Victorian lady, while in the later stories she is more of a tweedier & solid detective. It is this later Miss Marple that Julia has chosen for the personality in these episodes.
This set benefits from two mysteries that have not been dramatized before (correct me if I am wrong). The best being a Miss Marple short story THE BLUE GERANIUM, at an hour and a half it does not feel padded out. These are the stories that this new series should have gone for in the first place, rather than re-doing the earlier masterpieces by Joan Hickson. There are...
A Wonderful Production
Over the years, I have read all of Agatha Christie's Miss Marple mysteries and watched all of the modern film iterations of Miss Marple, played by everyone from the marvelous Joan Hickson to the latest grand dame, Julia McKenzie. Not surprisingly, my enjoyment of the series varied somewhat as each actress brought a different interpretation to the lead character and each production had its own atmosphere and style. The quality of the acting has never faltered, however, and many of Britain's finest actors have appeared in these mysteries. Series 5 with Julia McKenzie is a special delight. I was surprised at how lavish and rich the production quality is, how perfect the period details are -- especially in "The Mirror Crack'd." Joanna Lumley figured prominently in this episode and she is picture-perfect as Miss Marple's slightly ditsy and delightfully nosy friend, Dolly. Just to watch these two marvelous actresses interact is a joy. Lindsay Duncan also gives a first-rate performance...
Click to Editorial Reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment